For big league baseball player Buck Grimshaw, the world is falling apart. The end of his season is a disaster and his fiancé left him. At the moment he thought he hit bottom, the magic of Christmas Tree Falls called him back. That’s where he met Vince Manning, now a small-town teacher, his first love and the man who might help piece everything back together.

First, Vince has to deal with his painful memories over how they parted ten years earlier, and Buck has to face his ultimate fears of rejection. With help from friends Elaine, Ethan, and Teddy and grandfatherly figure, Nick, on their sides, Buck and Vince need to learn how to follow their hearts.